The Ritz-Carlton, Sarasota
$$$$ · Downtown, on Sarasota Bay
The full-service luxury option, on the bayfront downtown at 1111 Ritz-Carlton Drive. It isn't on the beach itself, but guests get the hotel's private Beach Club on Lido Key, with its own pool and restaurant, and a free shuttle across the Ringling Bridge that runs every hour.
Best if you want downtown restaurants and the arts scene at your door, with a beach day on call. There's also a spa, and a Tom Fazio-designed golf course out in Lakewood Ranch.